Sat 22 Jul 2006
If the idea is introduced, the idea can become a reality
Posted by Susan under Parental Watch Issues , Illinois Homeschool News , Mental Health Screening , Universal PreschoolMany parents and child advocates already knew this from sheer common sense. Along the same lines as telling the kids that you made cookies and stay out of the cookie jar (or candy jar).
The pharmaceutical industry is no dummy. They already knew this one. But people like ‘expert opinion’ and I guess they needed a study on that.
Marketing professors did a study and discovered this:
These findings should serve as a warning to public policy and health behavior researchers who routinely use surveys as a method to study risky behaviors, the researchers say.“We expected to find that students asked about exercise would exercise more, because that fits with past research regarding people’s motivation to conform with socially desirable behaviors,” said marketing professor Gavan Fitzsimons of Duke’s Fuqua School of Business. “What we weren’t expecting to see is that the students asked about drug use actually reported more, not less, use of illegal drugs.”
And of course, one of the plans for the Blueprint gang of the current governor’s is this; displayed in an IL House Resolution:
RESOLVED, That we recommend that every young person should be screened once during childhood or adolescence to identify mental illness and prevent suicide;
Every Young Person.
Continuing with the article:
“We’re working hard right now to better understand when questions may lead to these negative side effects,” Fitzsimons said. “For example, it appears that warning respondents in advance that asking questions can influence behavior may be a successful way to inoculate them against the potentially harmful effects of asking questions about risky behaviors.”
How dopey is this? Here’s the solution.
Don’t ask the flippin’ questions!
July 28th, 2006 at 8:11 pm
Susan,
As the parent of a child who is legitimately mentally ill let me say this is the stupidest thing I have ever heard of! Mental illness in children can be such a nebulous thing that it’s hard for those who specialize in it to identify sometimes. Who is going to do the screening? Teachers? Yeah, right, or maybe the ladies who come in and look for lice!
Another thing, those of us who are parents of legitimately mentally ill children would never let our children go without treatmenet of some kind. It’s heartbreaking to watch our kids go through and tests our love and patience to their limits!
July 29th, 2006 at 10:10 am
Thanks for your comment, Michelle. You addressed something that bothers me about the whole thing. That parents aren’t given the credibility and respect to assume that they will do right by and for their kids without Big Brother telling them when, what and where.
From what I read, the plan was to train people to conduct screenings in pre-schools (public and private), public schools, etc. and doctors’ offices during routine visits.
I hope you are finding all the help you need with your child, (and suspect that you’re not in your family’s real problem.)
July 31st, 2006 at 6:36 am
[…] That point was reiterated in comments here. […]