Sun 27 Jan 2008
State Legislatures are back in Action
Posted by Susan under Parental Watch Issues , Illinois Homeschool News , Mental Health Screening , Universal Preschool , Daytime Curfew , Homeschool NewsIllinois won’t be back in session until February 13.
Thank goodness.
In the mean time, Illinois Republican leader and Representative Dan Brady hit the 2008 session running. I wrote my opinion about the situation on the Illinois Review. It is not a homeschool issue. It is a typical example of the escalating and constant drumbeat from our legislators to use technology to the detriment of our freedoms.
What’s the Illinois Republican Conference Chair Doing?
Judy has some more info about that here:
Aside from that, homeschoolers should take note in this ‘brave, new world’ of increasing database sharing and networking within governmental agencies. Here’s an example that I pointed out recently concerning an Illinois driver’s education act that took away teens’ privacy rights with requirements of personal information being passed along to the Secretary of State’s office. Including homeschooled teens. (The fed DoE halted it because of FERPA.)
Illinois Driver’s Education Act considered unconstitutional
When I’m looking around for nasty legislation, I tend to head straight for the usual suspect anti-homeschool groups. The Illinois Association of School Boards has legislative reports updated by paid experts. I like to utilize their services.
A couple more are from the IFT Legislative Updates and the Capitol Report from IEA. Following that, most instigators of trouble for families leaving the public schools to homeschool are school administrators. Read Judy’s post about the CT. situation in Fighting Goliath. I’ve seen the same problems here in IL.
Public school administrators are hooked up with the Illinois Statewide School Management Alliance (IASB) posted above, which is an interesting story in itself. From my observations, the paid school administrators run the show while throwing out very refined tidbits of information to the school boards in order to direct the actions.
In other states, legislators have been busy. Dana of Principled Discovery posted this:
NE senator introduces legislation detrimental to homeschools
January 23, 2008, Senator Schimek of Lincoln, NE introduced Legislative Bill 1141, which would dramatically interfere with the independence of homeschools. Under current law, Nebraskan homeschools (referred to as unaccredited private schools) are “acknowledged” by the Commissioner of Education when the annual paperwork is received. This paperwork consists of an intent form, a calendar documenting at least 1,032 hours of instruction and a scope and sequence for each of several subject areas. Testing and record keeping are not required.
Under Senator Schimek’s bill, however, we will lose this independence. No longer will homeschools be “acknowledged,” we will be “approved” by the state. An option for visitations and testing has existed within our law for some time, however the state has never opted to enforce it.
And the basis for this bill would be what, you wonder? Precedent setting problems with adult Nebraska homeschoolers causing huge problems for The State The People? I don’t think so…..$$
Natalie Criss posted on the HEM Support Group News about Mississippi problems with homeschooling related perceptions blown out from various interests:
Drawing the line in Mississippi
Natalie raises a good point that has been useful in Illinois:
Clarity in language is a tool that must be utilized to combat confusion, educate families and expose opportunists. Other states have fought to make this distinction clear. The time has come to draw the line in Mississippi.
It’s hard enough with the media playing into teacher union’s hands with the big S word. Silly Socialization, that is. Chicago Teacher Union President Marilyn Stewart’s concerns are laughable at best. Creepy is the word that comes to my social and not quite as emotional mind:
"For them to think they can address the social and emotional issues of a child without being in the same room as that child is ludicrous," Stewart said. "You can only adequately address these issues in a classroom where you have necessary peer support and peer interaction."
Illinois has Social and Emotional Learning Standards that people like Stewart can rally from with one more piece of schoolie verbiage. Some more of that helps with job creation and expansion of the base. The School Machine keeps rolling bulldozing.
January 27th, 2008 at 1:59 pm
The lady who introduced this bill is married to the government relations guy of the NSEA, our state chapter of the NEA. I must say we are fortunate…this is the first time in over a decade legislation that would further restrict homeschooling has been introduced in our state.
January 27th, 2008 at 2:54 pm
It is amazing that we must monitor and watch our freedoms on so many fronts. Those surveillance cameras are all over my state of Ohio.
Perhaps we need to remind our legislators that trusting citizens is a good thing!
January 27th, 2008 at 3:22 pm
Great post.
January 27th, 2008 at 7:33 pm
Thanks, Alasandra. I wish there wasn’t this much material to write about in your home state and Nebraska..and elsewhere.
Dana, It’s been a while since the legislators have been that blatant here in IL too. (I think it was when they were trying to revise all of the school code almost 10 or so years ago.) They like coming in the back doors now.
But there have been a couple of detrimental laws that went through that changed what homeschoolers did in the past in IL. Private schoolers/homeschoolers now *have* to confirm transfer via notification to the formerly attended public school. It was a courtesy in the past. This provided a bit more protection to those families who didn’t notify in written form to prove they weren’t truant, but were actually homeschooling.
Ireally liked this quote from Jim Harper’s congressional testimony about this stoplight surveillance and privacy issues, Mary. As Members of Congress, your proper focus, the area where you can do the most productive work, and the area where you are
most responsible is privacy from government.
January 27th, 2008 at 11:26 pm
When I first read this, I was inclined to think it wouldn’t get too far. The capitol was virtually shut down the last time a law intruding on educational rights came up, and now senators actually call our state association before considering bills (this one is no exception).
But as I was reading up on the senators I learned some interesting things, and saw some things I hadn’t necessarily noticed before. Term limits are bringing Schimek’s legislative days to an end…without the concern of re-election, she has no fear of voters. Half of our senators were term limited out in ‘06 and the rest of the “old guard” will be out this year. I haven’t been able to see exactly how many that is, but with no concerns about re-election, I wonder how this will turn out?
Our state only recently got on board with the rest of the country in the creation of state standards and state assessments. With this push, it is only natural that they are going to be looking at the “unmeasured” homeschoolers. (And the guy who introduced that legislation happens to be the Chairperson of the Education Committee…with his 100% rating by the NSEA, our state chapter of the NEA.)
January 27th, 2008 at 11:31 pm
Maybe I’ll make an impassioned plea to Ernie Chambers (the guy who sued God). They say that term limits came about for the sole purpose of getting rid of him…he mucks up everything with his one man filibusters. There are several bills that legislators have just tucked away to wait until he is gone because there just isn’t any point to trying to get it past him.
So he’d be a good ally. Maybe if I can find a strong lobby of African American homeschoolers in Omaha, he’ll work his magic and kill this bill as he has so many others.
January 28th, 2008 at 8:01 am
Term limits!? Interesting. Your ed chair sounds a lot like our ed chair. She’s concerned about IL homeschoolers’ lack of accountability.
Illinois Has No Homeschool Regulations
I’ve noticed that a lot less regard is given to constituents expressing their concern about this or that. ‘Experts’ or The Authorities seem to have the upper hand too many times with legislators.
If Nebraska just recently got on board with the current standardized trends; watch out for those Social/Emotional Learning Standards. That’s a charmer that I would hate to see in any other state.
January 28th, 2008 at 8:03 am
Wish we had an Ernie Chambers (sorta
), who’d muck up any action in the legislature here. Less is always better in Springfield, imo.
January 29th, 2008 at 8:40 am
[…] Susan reminds us to stay civicly aware in State Legislatures are Back in Action, at Corn and Oil. […]